A Complete Timeline of Gigi Hadid and Zayn Malik’s Relationship

Gigi Hadid and Zayn Malik are many things: hot, rich, occasionally robots, and, also, occasionally together. The two of them reportedly first started dating in November 2015, and ever since then it’s been a roller coaster of cute Instagram posts, sound bites, breakup rumors, and his-and-her Nutella jars. Let’s take a look back at their relationship—including where it stands today.

November 2015: Us Weekly reports Hadid and Malik are dating. They were photographed leaving Justin Bieber’s American Music Awards after-party together; a few days later, paparazzi caught them holding hands leaving a restaurant in Los Angeles.

January 2016: Malik says he and Hadid are just “good friends,” but evidence—i.e., his face on Hadid’s lock screen—points to the contrary. Hadid then made an appearance in Malik’s “Pillowtalk” video, and they flirted back and forth on Twitter.

February 2016: Malik quasi-confirms he’s dating Hadid when radio interviewers refer to her as his girlfriend and he doesn’t correct them.

April 2016: The couple do a spread together in Naples for Vogue, which refers to Malik as Hadid’s “real-life boyfriend.” The next month they attended the Met Gala together.

June 2016: Several outlets report that Hadid and Malik have broken up, but she squashes those rumors in an interview with Elle magazine. Also, these his-and-her Nutella jars she shared on Instagram said a thousand words.

December 2016: They continue giving lovey-dovey quotes about each other. Malik revealed the “straight-up” way he asked Hadid out.

January 2017: Hadid sparks engagement rumors when she’s spotted wearing a ring on that finger. This turned out to be just, well, a rumor.