The 24 Nail Polish Shades We’ll Be Wearing All Winter

One annual tip-off that winter is ~officially~ here? Swapping the bright shades we’ve had in rotation for winter nail polish colors that feel more in line with sweater weather. We’re talking nail colors that look good peeking out of an oversized knit or under a sparkly clutch—or, let’s be real, with the beloved sweats we still can’t quit. Think of them as the mani equivalent of the first play of Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You”; the joy they bring is impossible to resist even if they’re hidden under gloves when you’re actually out and about.

With that time of year upon us, we enlisted our editors to share the shades they can’t wait to wear this season. While you’ll find the usual wintry mix of holiday red, glitters, and dark berries perfect for winter nail designs, there are also some more unexpected shades in the bunch—including the shade one editor chose for her recent engagement manicure. Read on for the best winter nail colors we’ll be reaching for all season.